Summer Feature: Atlantic City Race Course in Mays Landing

Real estate originally purchased by John Wesley Underhill

Mays Landing's first African American citizen was beloved by the children and residents who knew him for his candy shoppe on the corner of Farragut Avenue and Main Street. He owned and operated Underhill's, where they called him "Old John" until 1913. In the early years of the 20th century the KKK had a prescence in South Jersey, particularly in Mays Landing, but Underhill's  neighbors safeguarded the man they would later refer to as 'Our Citizen'. His funeral in 1925 included lying in honor in his bronze casket in the Atlantic County Courthouse, followed by a mile long procession to his final resting place in Union Cemetary, Mays Landing.

Bequeathed to the village of Mays Landing

The estate of John Underhill (valued at $100,000+) was left to the the town of Mays Landing, who's stated wishes were to build a gymnasium for the new school; a fountain and benches in the downtown park and play areas for children of the community, Underhill Park. The property that he invested in would later become the Atlantic City Race Course (ACRC) and was also gifted to his hometown.

Property was the (first) Mays Landing Country Club, relocated by Leo Fraser, past PGA president

Representatives of Mays Landing choose to use the newly acquired property to construct the (first) Mays Landing Country Club. Later, in 1962, Leo Fraser designed a new club and relocated to a 135 acre tract in Hamilton Township, paving the way for an even bigger attraction in Mays Landing.  

In 1946 investors pooled $4,000,000 to open the Atlantic City Race Course in Mays Landing

ACRC opened on July 22, 1946, as the Atlantic City Race Course, the work of a group of four individuals. The most famous of the group was John Kelly Sr., (Olympic Gold Medalist and father to Princess Grace Kelly of Monaco), created the race course together with Fred Scholler, Glendon Robertson and James "Sonny" Fraser.  Shareholders included show business personalities Frank Sinatra, Bob Hope, Harry James, Sammy Kaye and Xavier Cugat.

In 1969, the Race Course hosted a 3 Day Concert Event-two weeks ahead of Woodstock

On August 1, 2 and 3, 1969 an estimated 100,000 people attended the Atlantic City Pop Festival at the race course. A ticket for the entire three day weekend was $15. The overwhelming turn out was an unexpected and controversial state of affairs, as local government agencies and police departments were strained beyond their means.

In January 2015 the Race Course closed permanently

In 2015, Atlantic City Race Course closed, as gaming in other states saturated the market. The era of horse reacing in South Jersey was over on January 16th of that year. A portion of the property is now home to the Hamilton Mall and several restaurants, including: Olive Garden, Red Lobster, Longhorn and Chili's, as well as the BAM Shopping Center. The grandstand and track remain in a state of decline.

UNLOCKING OUR PAST in Hamilton Township

Hamilton Township's origins are directly tied to the Great Egg Harbor River and the tributaries that run through it. George May, after whom the village of May's Landing was named, built a shipyard and trading post near Babcock Creek in 1756. Colonel Richard Westcott served in the Revolutionary Army and settled in May's Landing in 1783,  where he kept a hotel, a store and mill. During the Revolutionary War, a local innkeeper and militia privateer, Captain Samuel Snell, is said to have captured 19 British ships off the river’s inlet, selling their cargo and ships at the docks at May's Landing. The early 1800’s saw Mays Landing become a thriving waterfront town with George Wheaton building over 100 sailing vessels with lumber harvested from area pine forests. In the 1850’s Senator William Moore owned a fleet of more that 50 sailing vessels engaging in commerce along the entire eastern seaboard.  His villa, the Sugar Hill Inn, sat perched on a high bluff overlooking the Great Egg Harbor River. Prized commodities of sugar, molasses and rum, arrived from the Far East by sailing ships and were stored in the walled foundation of the Inn, awaiting shipment to Philadelphia.  This part of town became known as Sugar Hill, a name still used to this day.  In nearby Weymouth, cannons and cannonballs for the War of 1812 were produced on the site of Atlantic County Park at Weymouth Furnace, until it was destroyed by fire. By the twentieth century, shipbuilding began to disappear with the decline in suitable resources. Iron was then substituted for ship hull construction.

Hamilton was incorporated as a township by an act of the New Jersey Legislature on February 5, 1813. Portions of Egg Harbor Township and Weymouth Township were acquired while the area was still part of Gloucester County. A Board of Freeholders was then established with representatives from four townships: Galloway, Hamilton, Egg Harbor and Weymouth. May's Landing was designated the county seat, while portions of the township were carved out to form Hammonton and Buena Vista Townships. The Freeholders first met on May 10, 1837 at the home of John Pennington in May's Landing. Among those first members were Pennington's brother-in-law Lewis M. Walker, owner of Walker's Forge and John Briggs, manager of the Weymouth Ironworks. Briggs worked for Samuel Richards, owner of the ironworks and a close friend of Walker's. Both Pennington and Richards offered up land to the county for the new buildings.  Soon a courthouse, jail and offices for the sheriff, clerk, and surrogate were constructed on the site that became the center for county business. Samuel Richards also built the American Hotel at the corner of Main Street and Farragut Avenue. The hotel opened for business in 1840 with William Wescoat as its first operator. Wescoat advertised the hotel as having an ideal site, excellent food, and fine accomodations.

In 1854 the first trains came through the area linking Camden with the new resort of Atlantic City. In 1871 a spur of the railroad was completed between Egg Harbor City and Mays Landing. By 1880, the railroad came to Mays Landing through the Newfield branch of the West Jersey and Atlantic Railroad Company. The line eventually merged into the West Jersey and Seashore Railroad and continued to operate until the mid twentieth century. Cotton milling had become the economic mainstay of the town for over eight decades, utilizing freight trains to transport goods and passenger trains to move people to cities up and down the east coast. The Mays Landing Water Power Company grew to become the town's largest employer, with modest company owned housing and a schoolhouse for their children (est 1903)-now home of the Hamilton Historical Society. The building on Mill Street that once housed the company’s general store and coal yard, also still stands as home to the local chapter of Mason’s. Additionally, R.D. Wood & Sons also owned factories in Millville and Florence, NJ.  While there were still farmers and shipbuilders scattered about the area in the late 1880s, the plant employed over 200 men, women and children, a figure that rose to approximately 300 throughout the 1890s. By the late 1930s approximately 25 percent of the town's workforce were still employed by the mill, until the end of it's 82 year reign.

In 1907, Father McCormick, who would become the first Pastor of the newly constructed St. Vincent de Paul Church,  approached the Leiland Family about opening their lakefront property for church picnics. With the success of having churchs as far out as Philadelphia coming to Mays Landing, the Leilands opened Lake Lenape Park officially in 1910. In 1939 the Leilands  commissioned Herman Dean Sr. to construct a 65 ft wooden lighthouse, referring to it as the 'singing tower', as a landmark for canoeists. In 1960, the Young Family bought the Park and reopened the indoor skating rink in 1973 after it had previously been destroyed by fire. Today Lake Lenape Park is a county property, while the skating rink has remained a family business.

In the summer of 1946, a group of prominent investors pooled $4,000,000 to open the Atlantic City Race Course in Mays Landing. Among the four were Jack Kelly-Philadelphia businessman and father of Grace Kelly; Fred Scholler; Glendon Robertson and James Fraser. Among the shareholders were: Frank Sinatra; Bob Hope; Harry James; Sammy Kaye and Xavier Cugat, When the doors opened on July 22, 1946, an estimated 25,000 fans came by buses, trains, planes and thousands of automobiles to witness the track’s first races. In it's last decades, gaming had expanded to states outside of New Jersey, ultimately leading to the track's closure in 2015. 

Another blow to the local economy came in 2014 when five of Atlantic City’s 12 casinos closed as New York and Pennsylvania tourists stayed closer to home. Today Hamilton Township sustains it's place as a bedroom community for Atlantic City, while also being South Jersey's largest retail shopping district. Outside of Atlantic City, Mays Landing is not only rich in history, but continues to offer the most options for movie theaters, dining choices, outdoor recreation and higher education in the Atlantic County region.

Stay Connected

Schoolhouse Museum  (far left)) on Mill Street

Upcoming Programs & Special Events

We are proud to bring you programs and presentations that are of local historic interest. Follow us on these two Facebook Pages: 

Hamilton Historical Society:

Mays Landing Yesteryear:

and stay informed with our '2018 Upcoming Events' web page on upcoming promotions and special events!

Get involved~Make A Difference in our community!

Are you interested in what we're about? Let us know! We'll help you find that committee that speaks to your interests

Thank you for your Support!

Whether you've helped the schoolhouse museum through monetary donations, volunteered your time, or participated in any of our community fundraisers, we thank you for supporting our Special Projects Team at the Hamilton Historical Society in Mays Landing  

Donations Appreciated


Pay with PayPal or a debit/credit card

We are dedicated to preserving the past of our community.

Please support our research to bring you the full story of the Aug 11, 1880 Train Disaster. Follow our page for updates on our progress!

Contact Us

Hamilton Historical Society

49 Mill Street Mays Landing, NJ 08330

(609) 909-0272


Thursday:  6PM - 9PM

Saturday: 10AM - 2PM

Become a Historical Society Member!